Garmin S4 Golf Watch Review

The Garmin S4 Golf Watch has been retired. Check out our current recommendations for today's best golf rangefinders..

UPDATE: Our Garmin S4 Golf Watch Review is a little bit dated. We still think this is a great watch, but there are newer Garmin Golf Watches that outperform the S4 and cost less. The new Garmin golf watches provide distances to hazards, where the S4 only includes layups and doglegs. The Garmin S4 is a solid golf watch, but the price would need to around $100 to make it a good value.

'Garmin S4 Golf Watch'

Garmin S4 Golf Watch
Not Available


Check Newer Models
Laser
GPS
Golf Watches


We’ve read dozens of user reviews and put the S4 to the test on several golf courses. First, let’s just say this is the slickest golf watch on the market and it does so many things well that it is our top pick in the golf watch category.

Garmin S4 Golf Watch User Rating: 4.06 Stars 4.06 out of 5 (276 reviews)

Score compiled from multiple sources.

For all it’s features, it is remarkably simple to navigate. The screen is easy to see and one touch will get you layup distances to the 50, 100, 150 and 200-yard markers. The touchscreen is perfectly responsive (once you realize it’s not supposed to be quite as sensitive to touch as your smartphone), the green view, scorecard and shot measuring features couldn’t be easier with dedicated buttons on the side of the watch. To move the pin, you press the green view button and press and drag your finger to the pin location and the distance will adjust. To enter your score, press the scorecard button and adjust the number of shots and easily add putts and fairways if you want. The watch calculates greens in regulation for you. If you use the scorecard on the first hole, it automatically pops up at the end of each hole, making it even more convenient. For all of that, the Garmin S4 is perfect!

There is one issue and it may be a factor for a few buyers. The S4 has the ability to connect to your iPhone via Bluetooth and display your text messages, emails, and other notifications right on the watch. It’s easy to pair the watch with your phone and amazingly unobtrusive. A small box displays the number of new messages on the screen when there are new messages. You can tap it to view the messages. The font for the messages is quite small, but you can adjust it by pressing the face once or twice and then scroll to read the whole message. You can easily go back and forth between your distances and your notifications. So what’s the issue? If you get too far away from your phone, the Bluetooth sometimes disconnects and does not always automatically reconnect. It won’t happen if you keep your phone in your pocket or clipped to your belt, but it happened way too often when the phone was left in the cart. Reconnecting wasn’t difficult, but it meant getting the phone out and turning the Bluetooth off and then back on. That defeats the purpose of having notifications in the first place, so for those who would use it with the intention of leaving it in a golf cart, don’t count on that feature. We reached out to other users and those who walked with their clubs and they had not experienced the problem. Even with this issue, we still think this coolest golf GPS watch on the market.

Garmin S4 Noteworthy Features
  • can display text and email messages and other notifications from your iPhone.
  • high resolution touchscreen easily readable even in bright sunlight
  • provides distance to the front, middle and back of every green, plus layups and doglegs.
  • dedicated “green view” button for easy access to manual pin positioning
  • detailed stat tracking
  • preloaded with over 30,000 golf courses
  • battery life lasts up to 10 hours in GPS mode.
  • waterproof to 10 meters
  • allows the creation of custom yardage points
Garmin S4 Golf Watch Specifications
Garmin S4 Golf Watch
Course Download Fees No
Pre-loaded with Courses Yes
Full Hole Views Yes
Slope / Elevation N/A
Battery Life 10 hrs GPS / 6 wks
Battery rechargeable Li-ion
Size (Width x Height x Depth) 2.41 in. x 1.83 in. x .58 in.
Measure Shot Distance Yes
Screen Size 1
Resolution 128 x 128
Display Type hi-res touchscreen
Weight 2.06 oz.
Rainproof Yes (10 meters)
Touch Screen Yes
Touch Targeting No
Manual Pin Positioning Yes
Stat Tracker Yes
Digital Scorecard Yes
Computer Analysis Tools Yes
Ground Verified N/A
Alternate Targets Yes
Green Rotates to your shot angle N/A
USGA Compliant (local rule) Yes
Notes Can receive email, text messages and notifications from smartphone. You can also print your scorecard from you computer after your round.
Order Golf Rangefinders from Amazon
GolfRangefinderShop.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you buy anything after clicking through, we get a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps us keep the site up and running, so thank you! We work very hard to obtain the correct information about product features, but cannot make any guarantees about the accuracy. Please double check with the merchant or manufacturer before making a purchase.

User Manual for Garmin S4 Golf Watch

Most Accurate GPS Watch

What’s the most accurate GPS watch for golf? It’s a question we’re hearing a lot lately as golf watches have become incredibly popular.

We believe all of our top picks have excellent satellite receivers that are quite capable of getting the job done. There are other factors that affect GPS, and on the golf course, trees seem to be the biggest interference.

The question of how accurate the course maps are, is tricky as well. If you’re using a GPS for golf, you will eventually run into some distances that are off. However the feedback we’ve seen on our favorite GPS golf watches is extremely positive with regards to accuracy. Of course there’s almost always at least one complaint. Whether the blame should go to the maps or the trees is hard to say.

The GolfBuddy VT3 watch and SkyCaddie golf watch use maps that have been ground-verified, meaning that someone has actually been to every course and verified the distances. Whether or not this makes those models more accurate is uncertain, however the SkyCaddie watch charges annual fees and doesn’t get reviews that measure up to the competition. GolfBuddy doesn’t charge additional fees on any of their golf GPS products, so we will keep a close eye on the VT3 reviews.

Garmin vs Bushnell Golf Watch 2022

Garmin vs Bushnell Golf WatchOnce upon a time, the Garmin vs Bushnell Golf Watch conversation was worth having. Although Bushnell does still offer a golf watch, the ratings are lousy and we just cannot recommend it.

Garmin on the other hand, has continued to dominate the golf watch category. While most of their watches are high-end and feature-rich, they also offer a more affordable option in the Garmin Approach S12, which is no slouch when it comes to features.

When it comes to feature-loaded golf watches, Garmin has nailed it…(Keep reading below)

Keep in mind that Garmin has been doing sports watches for a very long time and it’s no surprise how well they balance features with ease of use, not to mention they have some of the best-looking golf watches we’ve seen.

Most if not all of the currently available Garmin golf watches have a scorecard and stats feature. They have made recording your putts, fairways hit, and greens in regulation, an easy thing to do. Even better, you can access analysis of this information on your computer or an app on your smartphone. If you are looking to find the weak spots in your game, this can be very helpful.

Several of the Garmin golf watches allow touch targeting of the pin location and some even have touch targeting on fairway views. There are even Garmin golf watches that measure distance and record shot locations for post-round analysis.

Beyond the golf features, many of these watches are adding smartwatch features. Smartphone notifications, fitness tracking, sleep tracking, and more have been smoothly integrated into Garmin’s line of golf watches. Garmin even has a few multi-sport watches that include golf, which is a real bonus for multi-sport athletes.

There’s not really enough praise to heap on Garmin for the variety of choices and outstanding implementation. Check out our complete list of Garmin Golf Watch summaries .

GolfBuddy VT3 + Watch Review

The GolfBuddy VT3 has been retired. Check out our current recommendations for today's best golf rangefinders..

'GolfBuddy VT3 '

GolfBuddy VT3
Not Available


Check Newer Models
Laser
GPS
Golf Watches


Here are our preliminary thoughts for our GolfBuddy VT3 + Watch Review…

GolfBuddy VT3 User Rating: 3.00 Stars 3.00 out of 5 (11 reviews)

Score compiled from multiple sources.

The GolfBuddy Voice became a huge success not only with golfers who needed the auditory prompts, but with a much broader audience because of the size and performance. GolfBuddy is capitalizing on that success with several new units, including the VT3 which does not have the voice prompts, but has a touch screen and offers the versatility of working as a golf GPS watch or it can be detached from the band and will fit on a belt clip or visor, or easily into your pocket.

The VT3 has lots of features, including manual pin placement, shot measuring and a scorecard. On the other hand, you can simply leave it on the main screen and you will get distances to the front, middle and back of every green. The GolfBuddy VT3 comes preloaded with over 36,000 golf courses worldwide and never has any fees.

We’re definitely excited about the GolfBuddy VT3 and look forward to seeing how it stands up to the competition as both a golf GPS watch or simply as a small golf GPS.

GolfBuddy VT3
Course Download Fees No
Pre-loaded with Courses Yes
Full Hole Views Yes
Slope / Elevation N/A
Battery Life 10 hrs
Battery Li-poly rechargeable
Size (Width x Height x Depth) 1.72 in. x 1.68 in. x .38 in.
Measure Shot Distance Yes
Screen Size 1.5
Resolution N/A
Display Type LCD 16 Gray
Weight .95 oz.
Rainproof No
Touch Screen Yes
Touch Targeting Yes
Manual Pin Positioning Yes
Stat Tracker No
Digital Scorecard Yes
Computer Analysis Tools No
Ground Verified Yes
Alternate Targets Yes
Green Rotates to your shot angle Yes
USGA Compliant (local rule) Yes
Notes May be used with or without the included watch band. Can also be used as a GPS watch for tracking distance and time for walkers/runners.
Order Golf Rangefinders from Amazon
GolfRangefinderShop.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you buy anything after clicking through, we get a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps us keep the site up and running, so thank you! We work very hard to obtain the correct information about product features, but cannot make any guarantees about the accuracy. Please double check with the merchant or manufacturer before making a purchase.

Bushnell NEO-X GPS Watch Review

The Bushnell NEO-X Watch has been retired. Check out our current recommendations for today's best golf rangefinders..

'Bushnell NEO-X Watch'

Bushnell NEO-X Watch
Not Available


Check Newer Models
Laser
GPS
Golf Watches


With a price this reasonable and reviews this good, why wouldn’t you want to buy the Bushnell Neo-X GPS golf watch? The answer to the question isn’t the same for every golfer, but we can break it down for you fairly quickly…

Bushnell NEO-X Watch User Rating: 4.39 Stars 4.39 out of 5 (469 reviews)

Score compiled from multiple sources.
  1. If you want a digital scorecard, this isn’t the watch for you. (Try the Garmin S3 or S4.)
  2. If you want more than two hazards per hole, this isn’t the watch for you. (Try the Bushnell Neo XS.)
  3. If you prefer a round face, this isn’t the watch for you. (Try any of those three watches in the first two bullet points!)

Otherwise, there’s no good reason not to buy the Bushnell Neo-X. It has 30,000 golf courses preloaded with distances to the front, middle and back of every green, plus easy access to hazard and layup distances. It’s got the usual Auto Course Recogition, Auto Hole Advance, Shot Measuring and Round Odometer. It’s also among the best when it comes to battery life and there are no membership fees or required downloads.

Review after review had almost nothing but high praise for one of the smallest and lightest golf GPS watches on the market. Over 88% of all the comments we read were positive. The top mentions were accuracy, ease of use and good battery life. Quite a few users mentioned that it was easy to read with big numbers. Overall, the negative comments were sparse and seldom repeated.

Bushnell NEO-X Watch Specifications
Bushnell NEO-X Watch
Course Download Fees No
Pre-loaded with Courses Yes
Full Hole Views Yes
Slope / Elevation No
Battery Life up to 16 hours
Battery Rechargeable
Size (Width x Height x Depth) 1.4 in. x 1.5 in. x .6 in.
Measure Shot Distance Yes
Screen Size N/A
Resolution N/A
Display Type N/A
Weight 1.8 oz.
Rainproof Waterproof
Touch Screen No
Touch Targeting No
Manual Pin Positioning No
Stat Tracker No
Digital Scorecard No
Computer Analysis Tools No
Ground Verified No
Alternate Targets Yes
Green Rotates to your shot angle N/A
USGA Compliant (local rule) Yes
Notes Odometer, Tee Time Start & Auto GPS Off
Order Golf Rangefinders from Amazon
GolfRangefinderShop.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you buy anything after clicking through, we get a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps us keep the site up and running, so thank you! We work very hard to obtain the correct information about product features, but cannot make any guarantees about the accuracy. Please double check with the merchant or manufacturer before making a purchase.

User Manual for Bushnell NEO-X Watch

See our Comparison of Golf GPS Watches.